«Dear Reader: In order to view all colored text and non-English text accurately, please ensure that the PUBLISHER DEFAULTS SETTING on your reading ...»
Dear Reader: In order to view all
colored text and non-English text
accurately, please ensure that the
PUBLISHER DEFAULTS SETTING on
your reading device is switched to ON.
This will allow you to view all nonEnglish characters and colored text in
this book. —Tuttle Publishing
The naimon (inner gate) of the Kantakeyama
Shinen at the Samukawa Shrine opens toward
the eight-sided stone marker indicating the
source of the water in the Namba no Koike pond.
A simple bamboo spout drips water into the chōzubachi (water basin) in the Shōjutei garden at the private residence Rifugio.
The Suitōkyosei courtyard garden provides views of refined nature from the head priest’s office and the adjoining tatami room at the Gionji temple reception building.
THE COMPLETE WORKS OF
JAPAN’S LEADING GARDEN
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Locher, Mira.
Zen gardens: the complete works of Shunmyo Masuno, Japan’s leading garden designer.—1st ed.
Author: Mira Locher.
Includes bibliographical references.
ISBN: 978-1-4629-1049-6 (ebook)
1. Gardens, Japanese—Zen influences. 2. Gardens—
Design. 3. Masuno, Shunmyo. I. Title. II. Title:
Complete works of Shunmyo Masuno, Japan’s leading garden designer.
SB458.L63 2012 635.9’77373—dc23 Distributed by North America, Latin America & Europe Tuttle Publishing 364 Innovation Drive, North Clarendon, VT 05759U.S.A.
Tel: 1 (802) 773-8930; Fax: 1 (802) 773-6993 firstname.lastname@example.org; www.tuttlepublishing.com Japan Tuttle Publishing Yaekari Building, 3rd Floor, 5-4-12 Osaki, Shinagawaku, Tokyo 141-0032 Tel: (81) 3 5437-0171; Fax: (81) 3 5437-0755 email@example.com; www.tuttle.co.jp Asia Pacific Berkeley Books Pte. Ltd.
61 Tai Seng Avenue #02-12, Singapore 534167 Tel: (65) 6280-1330; Fax: (65) 6280-6290 firstname.lastname@example.org; www.periplus.com First edition Printed in Singapore 1206CP TUTTLE PUBLISHING® is a registered trademark of Tuttle Publishing, a division of Periplus Editions (HK) Ltd.
The evening light shimmers in the quiet reflecting pool of the Shōka no Niwa (Ascension Garden) in the Yūkyūen garden at the Hofu City Crematorium.
A nobedan (stone walkway) and steppingstones lead to the shihō hotoke tsukubai chōzubachi (four-sided Buddha water basin) in the Mushintei garden at the Suifūso guesthouse.
contents Foreword by Shigeru Uchida Two Pairs of Straw 10 Sandals: Zen Priest Garden Designer Shunmyo Masuno 21 Notes on Language
GARDENSTraditional Zen Gardens in the 21st Century 26 SŌSEIEN, RETREAT HOUSE GINRINSŌ, COMPANY
RECEPTION HALL40 ART LAKE GOLF CLUB
48 RYŪMONTEI, GIONJI TEMPLE
FUSHOTEI, RENSHŌJI TEMPLE
56 KAKUSHOKAKU RECEPTIONHALL 60 SANDŌ, KŌENJI TEMPLE
SHŌJUTEI, RIFUGIO PRIVATE
CHŌFŪTEI AND SUITŌKYOSEI,
74 GIONJI TEMPLE RECEPTION
78 BAIKATEI, SAIKENJI TEMPLE
RESIDENCE IN YAMANAKA-KO84 CHŌSETSUKO, GINRINSŌ RYŌKAN 86 CHŌRAITEI, PRIVATE
RESIDENCE IN TOKYO
KEIZAN ZENJI TENBŌRIN NO
NIWA, GOTANJŌJI TEMPLE
SAMUKAWA SHRINEDesign and Construction Process: The Kantakeyama Shinen at the Samukawa Shrine
Modern Zen Gardens:
114 The Essence of Emptiness
NEW CAMPUS FOR TOKYO
THE CANADIAN EMBASSY,TOKYO
FŪMA BYAKUREN PLAZA,126 NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR
MUSEUM OF MODERN ART
SEIFŪ KYORAI NO NIWA,134 KAGAWA PREFECTURAL
SEIZAN RYOKUSUI NO NIWA,136 HOTEL LE PORT
KANZATEI, CERULEAN TOWER
YŪKYŪEN, HOFU CITY
CREMATORIUMSEIFŪDŌKŌ NO NIWA, OPUS 152 ARISUGAWA TERRACE AND
SANKITEI, MINISTRY OF
YUI NO NIWA SHINSHŌTEI,
160 PRIVATE RESIDENCE IN NISHIAZABU Mondō: A Dialogue 166 with Shunmyo Masuno
OUTSIDEJAPAN Zen Gardens Outside 174 Japan: Intercultural Communication
WAKEI NO NIWA, CANADIAN
MUSEUM OF CIVILIZATION
MARZAHN188 SEIJAKU NO NIWA,
UNIVERSITY OF BERGEN
SANSHINTEI, ONE KOWLOON192 OFFICE BUILDING
FUNITEI, PRIVATE RESIDENCE
ZANMAITEI, NASSIM PARK
WAKEISEIJYAKU NO NIWA,
NASSIM PARK RESIDENCES
SEIKANTEI, PRIVATE212 RESIDENCE IN NEW YORK CITY 216 Major Works 1984–2011 218 Endnotes 220 Glossary 222 Acknowledgments 223 Bibliography The contemporary karesansui (dry) garden at the Suifūso guesthouse, chōzubachi (water basin) at the Chūraitei private garden, the Japanese garden at the Canadian Embassy in Tokyo, the Yūsuien garden at the Erholungspark Marzahn, the Kanzatei garden at the Cerulean Tower Tokyu Hotel, and the Yui no Niwa Shinshūtei private garden.
SHIGERU UCHIDAThis is entirely my own personal opinion: however, by coming into contact with many designs, I have become aware that there are two directions for design themes. They are the way to grasp a “thing” or “object” as a subject and the way to consider a “relationship” as a subject. Supposing we call the former “object as precedent,” the latter can be called “relationship as precedent.” Japanese culture is that in which everything is “relationship as precedent.” Many Western cultures can be seen as cultures with “object as precedent.” However, in that case the “thing” is the subject; by no means is it the predicate. In relational philosophy, formerly a relationship firstly had independent content, and it was thought that within that content, that relationship came into being.
However, recently it is thought that it is “unequivocal only because of the relationship.” The “relationship as precedent” is predicate logic. First of all, more than the subject, the predicate is valued. Independent meaning is removed from all things, then things come into existence only in the situation they fall into and in the circumstance of a relationship.
Things do not always display their fixed nature. Depending on the situation things fall into and the circumstances, even if they are the same, they create different meanings.
The first obstacle encountered in symbolic logic is probably when the concept of subject and predicate appeared within “predicate logic.” In the words “I am a designer,” first of all “I” exists, whether that existence is “designer” or “man” or else “Japanese person” is realized as a modifier or as a predicate. In any case, to begin with, there is a subject, one’s identity is ensured.
With regard to that, a pattern of something that can be described is in the background.
However, in predicate logic it becomes “subject is change.” If that is the case, the situation changes completely. Namely, where the modifier of being a “designer” does not change, but the changing of “I,” which becomes the subject, is required. In other words, in “predicate logic” the important thing is the modifier “designer.” The meaning of this content becomes the modifier. In Japanese culture, a relationship is such.
The rock arrangements in the gardens of Masuno Shunmyo also are thus. In regard to rocks as a subject, that predicate relationship of how they are arranged is important. The project of the Kantakeyama Shinen at the Samukawa shrine, through phase one and phase two, is an enormous undertaking. This kind of garden project is not formed with just one point of view. Most essential in Masuno’s garden design is the division of land. Namely, depending on the spatial composition of the site, first the framework is formed.
Here is a chisenkaiyushiki-teien (pond stroll garden), and attached to it are a chaya (tea pavilion) and chashitsu (teahouse). Furthermore, there is a Zen garden, and as an extension of the main hall [of the shrine], there also are the Kantakeyama mountain, a chinju no mori (sacred grove), and the Namba no Koike pond. A major theme is how to create a relationship between each of these things that has its own individual meaning. Moreover, on top of these relationships, each of their parts also comes into existence. The relationships of these parts and the overall relationship of many elements—these are composed depending on Masuno’s studied intention.
For example, the relationship of the ryūmonbaku [literally, “dragon’s gate waterfall”] and the stone bridge depends on the combination of rock arrangements and water, giving the viewer a profound impression and sense of grandeur.
Also the contrast of the natural rock of the ryūmonbaku and the rectilinearly hewn stone bridge produces a feeling of tension in these surroundings.
Also more pure than anything is the scenery from the Warakutei tea pavilion (chaya). Compared to the teahouse (chashitsu), that pleasure of the tea pavilion, the abounding sense of entertainment in the variation of the pond garden, is expressed. Even so, Masuno’s architectural skill truly is to be admired. To say what is good, it is the superb relationship between the garden and the architecture. This is because it is architecture made by the designer with the garden as the theme. It is easy if we say the relationship to the garden is superb, but that atmosphere exists because the architecture does not forcibly assert itself, yet it isn’t restrained.
The relationship of the architecture and the pond as viewed from the garden is something truly beautiful.
Also, when the garden is viewed from the interior horizontal opening, that horizontality comes together with the garden and rushes inside the room.
I also want to verify [these relationships in] other projects, but I’ll keep it to this. What one can feel from Masuno’s projects regards “relationality” and “object-ness.” However, so there is no misunderstanding here, in many cases depending on their complementarity, things are completed. What is important here is which thinking comes first. In all Japanese culture, relationality comes first.
Nighttime lighting softly illuminates the rock arrangements and raked gravel of the Chōsetsuko courtyard garden at the Ginrinsō Ryōkan.
Two Pairs of
Zen Priest Garden Designer Shunmyo Masuno Shunmyo Masuno saws off the branches of bamboo stalks to use in the construction of a garden fence.
“The garden is a special spiritual place where the mind dwells.”1 For Shunmyo Masuno, this is the ultimate meaning of the Zen garden, coming from years of training, both as a Zen Buddhist priest and as a garden designer.
These two roles are inseparable in his life, as he describes with the Japanese expression “wearing two pairs of straw sandals” (nisoku no waraji wo haku).2 Garden making is a form of mental and physical training for Masuno, an act of selfcultivation akin to the training of a martial artist. Such acts of selfcultivation are required in the practice of Zen Buddhism.